Freedom First
Freedom First

Home » Archive

Issue No.: 573 | March 2015
 

People to People Contact – Cant’ Resolve the Indo-Pakistan Conflict

Suresh C. Sharma
back
vv9v8v09fq:ds_article:1;2;3;4;5;6;7;8;9;10;11;12;13;14;15;16;17;18;19;20;21;22;23;24;25;26;27;28;29;30;31;32;33;34;35;36;37;38;39;40;41;42;43;44;45;46;47;48;49;50;51;52;53;54;55;56;57;58;59;60;61;62;63;64;65;66;67;68;69;70;71;72;73;74;75;76;77;78;79;80;81;82;83;84;85;86;87;88;89;90;91;92;93;94;95;96;97;98;99;100;101;102;103;104;105;106;107;108;109;110;111;112;113;114;115;116;117;118;119;120;121;122;123;124;125;126;127;128;129;130;131;132;133;134;135;136;137;138;139;140;141;142;143;144;145;146;147;148;149;150;151;152;153;154;155;156;157;158;159;160;161;162;163;164;165;166;167;168;169;170;171;172;173;174;175;176;177;178;179;180;181;182;183;184;185;186;187;188;189;190;191;192;193;194;195;196;197;198;199;200;201;202;203;204;205;206;207;208;209;210;211;212;213;214;215;216;217;218;219;220;221;222;223;224;225;226;227;228;229;230;231;232;233;234;235;236;237;238;239;240;241;242;243;244;245;246;247;248;249;250;251;252;253;254;255;256;257;258;259;260;261;262;263;264;265;266;267;268;269;270;271;272;273;274;275;276;277;278;279;280;281;282;283;284;285;286;287;288;289;290;291;292;293;294;295;296;297;298;299;300;301;302;303;304;305;306;307;308;309;310;311;312;313;314;315;316;317;318;319;320;321;322;323;324;325;326;327;328;329;330;331;332;333;334;335;336;337;338;339;340;341;342;343;344;345;346;347;348;349;350;351;352;353;354;355;356;357;358;359;360;361;362;363;364;365;366;367;368;369;370;371;372;373;374;375;376;377;378;379;380;381;382;383;384;385;386;387;388;389;390;391;392;393;394;395;396;397;398;399;400;401;402;403;404;405;406;407;408;409;410;411;412;413;414;415;416;417;418;419;420;421;422;423;424;425;426;427;428;429;430;431;432;433;434;435;436;437;438;439;440;441;442;443;444;445;446;447;448;449;450;451;452;453;454;455;456;457;458;459;460;461;462;463;464;465;466;467;468;469;470;471;472;473;474;475;476;477;478;479;480;481;482;483;484;485;486;487;488;489;490;491;492;493;494;495;496;497;498;499;500;501;502;503;504;505;506;507;508;509;510;511;512;513;514;515;516;517;518;519;520;521;522;523;524;525;526;527;528;529;530;531;532;533;534;535;536;537;538;539;540;541;542;543;544;545;546;547;548;549;550;551;552;553;554;555;556;557;558;559;560;561;562;563;564;565;566;567;568;569;570;571;572;573;574;575;576;577;578;579;580;581;582;583;584;585;586;587;588;589;590;591;592;593;594;595;596;597;598;599;600;601;602;603;604;605;606;607;608;609;610;611;612;613;614;615;616;617;618;619;620;621;622;623;624;625;626;627;628;629;630;631;632;633;634;635;636;637;638;639;640;641;642;643;644;645;646;647;648;649;650;651;652;653;654;655;656;657;658;659;660;661;662;663;664;665;666;667;668;669;670;671;672;673;674;675;676;677;678;679;680;681;682;683;684;685;686;687;688;689;690;691;692;693;694;695;696;697;698;699;700;701;702;703;704;705;706;707;708;709;710;711;712;713;714;715;716;717;718;719;720;721;722;723;724;725;726;727;728;729;730;731;732;733;734;735;736;737;738;739;740;741;742;743;744;745;746;747;748;749;750;751;752;753;754;755;756;757;758;759;760;761;762;763;764;765;766;767;768;769;770;771;772;773;774;775;776;777;778;779;780;781;782;783;784;785;786;787;788;789;790;791;792;793;794;795;796;797;798;799;800;801;802;803;804;805;806;807;808;809;810;811;812;813;814;815;816;817;818;819;820;821;822;823;824;825;826;827;828;829;830;831;832;833;834;835;836;837;838;839;840;841;842;843;844;845;846;847;848;849;850;851;852;853;854;855;856;857;858;859;860;861;862;863;864;865;866;867;868;869;870;871;872;873;874;875;876;877;878;879;880;881;882;883;884;885;886;887;888;889;890;891;892;893;894;895;896;897;898;899;900;901;902;903;904;905;906;907;908;909;910;911;912;913;914;915;916;917;918;919;920;921;922;923;924;925;926;927;928;929;930;931;932;933;934;935;936;937;938;939;940;941;942;943;944;945;946;947;948;949;950;951;952;953;954;955;956;957;958;959;960;961;962;963;964;965;966;967;968;969;970;971;972;973;974;975;976;977;978;979;980;981;982;983;984;985;986;987;988;989;990;991;992;993;994;995;996;997;998;999;1000;1001;1002;1003;1004;1005;1006;1007;1008;1009;1010;1011;1012;1013;1014;1015;1016;1017;1018;1019;1020;1021;1022;1023;1024;1025;1026;1027;1028;1029;1030;1031;1032;1033;1034;1035;1036;1037;1038;1039;1040;1041;1042;1043;1044;1045;1046;1047;1048;1049;1050;1051;1052;1053;1054;1055;1056;1057;1058;1059;1060;1061;1062;1063;1064;1065;1066;1067;1068;1069;1070;1071;1072;1073;1074;1075;1076;1077;1078;1079;1080;1081;1082;1083;1084;1085;1086;1087;1088;1089;1090;1091;1092;1093;1094;1095;1096;1097;1098;1099;1100;1101;1102;1103;1104;1105;1106;1107;1108;1109;1110;1111;1112;1113;1114;1115;1116;1117;1118;1119;1120;1121;1122;1123;1124;1125;1126;1127;1128;1129;1130;1131;1132;1133;1134;1135;1136;1137;1138;1139;1140;1141;1142;1143;1144;1145;1146;1147;1148;1149;1150;1151;1152;1153;1154;1155;1156;1157;1158;1159;1160;1161;1162;1163;1164;1165;1166;1167;1168;1169;1170;1171;1172;1173;1174;1175;1176;1177;1178;1179;1180;1181;1182;1183;1184;1185;1186;1187;1188;1189;1190;1191;1192;1193;1194;1195;1196;1197;1198;1199;1200;1201;1202;1203;1204;1205;1206;1207;1208;1209;1210;1211;1212;1213;1214;1215;1216;1217;1218;1219;1220;1221;1222;1223;1224;1225;1226;1227;1228;1229;1230;1231;1232;1233;1234;1235;1236;1237;1238;1239;1240;1241;1242;1243;1244;1245;1246;1247;1248;1249;1250;1251;1252;1253;1254;1255;1256;1257;1258;1259;1260;1261;1262;1263;1264;1265;1266;1267;1268;1269;1270;1271;1272;1273;1274;1275;1276;1277;1278;1279;1280;1281;1282;1283;1284;1285;1286;1287;1288;1289;1290;1291;1292;1293;1294;1295;1296;1297;1298;1299;1300;1301;1302;1303;1304;1305;1306;1307;1308;1309;1310;1311;1312;1313;1314;1315;1316;1317;1318;1319;1320;1321;1322;1323;1324;1325;1326;1327;1328;1329;1330;1331;1332;1333;1334;1335;1336;1337;1338;1339;1340;1341;1342;1343;1344;1345;1346;1347;1348;1349;1350;1351;1352;1353;1354;1355;1356;1357;1358;1359;1360;1361;1362;1363;1364;1365;1366;1367;1368;1369;1370;1371;1372;1373;1374;1375;1376;1377;1378;1379;1380;1381;1382;1383;1384;1385;1386;1387;1388;1389;1390;1391;1392;1393;1394;1395;1396;1397;1398;1399;1400;1401;1402;1403;1404;1405;1406;1407;1408;1409;1410;1411;1412;1413;1414;1415;1416;1417;1418;1419;1420;1421;1422;1423;1424;1425;1426;1427;1428;1429;1430;1431;1432;1433;1434;1435;1436;1437;1438;1439;1440;1441;1442;1443;1444;1445;1446;1447;1448;1449;1450;1451;1452;1453;1454;1455;1456;1457;1458;1459;1460;1461;1462;1463;1464;1465;1466;1467;1468;1469;1470;1471;1472;1473;1474;1475;1476;1477;1478;1479;1480;1481;1482;1483;1484;1485;1486;1487;1488;1489;1490;1491;1492;1493;1494;1495;1496;1497;1498;1499;1500;1501;1502;1503;1504;1505;1506;1507;1508;1509;1510;1511;1512;1513;1514;1515;1516;1517;1518;1519;1520;1521;1522;1523;1524;1525;1526;1527;1528;1529;1530;1531;1532;1533;1534;1535;1536;1537;1538;1539;1540;1541;1542;1543;1544;1545;1546;1547;1548;1549;1550;1551;1552;1553;1554;1555;1556;1557;1558;1559;1560;1561;1562;1563;1564;1565;1566;1567;1568;1569;1570;1571;1572;1573;1574;1575;1576;1577;1578;1579;1580;1581;1582;1583;1584;1585;1586;1587;1588;1589;1590;1591;1592;1593;1594;1595;1596;1597;1598;1599;1600;1601;1602;1603;1604;1605;1606;1607;1608;1609;1610;1611;1612;1613;1614;1615;1616;1617;1618;1619;1620;1621;1622;1623;1624;1625;1626;1627;1628;1629;1630;1631;1632;1633;1634;1635;1636;1637;1638;1639;1640;1641;1642;1643;1644;1645;1646;1647;1648;1649;1650;1651;1652;1653;1654;1655;1656;1657;1658;1659;1660;1661;1662;1663;1664;1665;1666;1667;1668;1669;1670;1671;1672;1673;1674;1675;1676;1677;1678;1679;1680;1681;1682;1683;1684;1685;1686;1687;1688;1689;1690;1691;1692;1693;1694;1695;1696;1697;1698;1699;1700;1701;1702;1703;1704;1705;1706;1707;1708;1709;1710;1711;1712;1713;1714;1715;1716;1717;1718;1719;1720;1721;1722;1723;1724;1725;1726;1727;1728;1729;1730;1731;1732;1733;1734;1735;1736;1737;1738;1739;1740;1741;1742;1743;1744;1745;1746;1747;1748;1749;1750;1751;1752;1753;1754;1755;1756;1757;1758;1759;1760;1761;1762;1763;1764;1765;1766;1767;1768;1769;1770;1771;1772;1773;1774;1775;1776;1777;1778;1779;1780;1781;1782;1783;1784;1785;1786;1787;1788;1789;1790;1791;1792;1793;1794;1795;1796;1797;1798;1799;1800;1801;1802;1803;1804;1805;1806;1807;1808;1809;1810;1811;1812
At the 18th SAARC meet, more than any tangible action, what resonated more was the call by Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Pakistan to upgrade China from its present observer status to the status of a member.

Nations are characterized by the key elements of their national character. As an illustration, it is the "elementary force and persistence of the Russian, the individual initiative and inventiveness of the American, the common sense of the British and the discipline and the thoroughness of the German. The Hindu is a more complex personality and displays a combination of key traits based on varying power equations…In the case of a most powerful adversary it is patience, passivity, deceit and a persistent attempt to corrupt the powerful to his own outlook. …most appropriate [though an oversimplification] would be a "presumptuous, persistence and devious Hindu.”  - Lt.Col. [later Lt.Gen] Javed Hassan

[A text book for Pakistan Army has been distributed by military book club and reveals the mind-set of Pakistan’s military officers.] 

People to people contact can be promoted by tourism, trade, military collaboration or joint ventures. Tourism is a far cry for people of both the countries since there are more interesting destinations in Europe, the USA and the Far East. Some people who migrated from one of the countries in 1947 may like to visit their old homes. They however, soon get disillusioned by the present condition of their erstwhile homes and with the reaction of the residents. There is hardly any recognition. Nor would it be a pleasure to refresh the tortures that had been inflicted on them. Illegal trade is already a big business across the border. There is little chance of increase in trade due to India being denied the ‘Most Favourable’ status. As an example, consider Ambani’s project to produce gas in Pakistan and transport it to India by a pipeline. Foreign Minister I. K. Gujral talked about it to Prime Minister Sharif. Foreign Secretary Shamshad Ahmed Khan interrupted Sharif to say that such a project could be considered only after a satisfactory solution of the Kashmir problem. That has been the position taken by Pakistan on every issue. Moreover Pakistan and India would prefer to import capital goods from China or Western countries due to the advantages of quality, political favours and credit. Military collaboration or joint ventures are not possible. Perhaps, contacts can be promoted only by sponsored visits which give a wrong picture to the visitors and hosts due to lack of realism and artificial smiles.

Obstacles in the Path for Better Relations

The first major obstacle is in every Pakistani considering himself to be an heir to the Muslim Empire and a custodian of the wellbeing of Muslims in India. Visitors from Pakistan notice only the poverty amongst the Muslims and forget that there are a large number of poor amongst the Hindus too. A Pakistani Lt. Colonel told a journalist that "to be frank, we are brought up from the cradle to be ready to fight India. On joining the army, the feeling gets multiplied.” The madrasas have added to this feeling but even if all the madrasas are closed down, the hostility would not vanish. A large number of terrorists have studied in government schools. They have joined militant organizations due to Islamism amongst the masses, particularly in the lower middle classes. They have widespread support for attacking India. Let us look at what the Pakistani elites say about India. Shah Waliullah advised that Islam could survive in India only if Muslims maintained physical, ideological and emotional distance from Hindus. His sons continued his mission.

Vajpayee went out of his way to visit Lahore in February 1999 to meet Sharif. The road from Amritsar to the border was decorated with flowers and the people expected some positive results. There was no similar public attendance in Pakistan. Instead, there were demonstrations against the visit which had to be put down by the police. A group of religious leaders washed the platform on which Vajpayee stood to purify it since it had been polluted by an "infidel prime minister.” The Pakistan media or the intellectuals did not criticize it. Kuldip Nayar led a crowd of about 500 people with candle light vigil but no one came from the Pakistan side.

India, a Punching Bag for Pakistan

In 2008, the Political Officer at the US Consulate was ambushed by the Taliban and saved by a bulletproof car. Professor Azmat Hyat Khan, Head of the Area Studies Centre at the Peshawar University commented, "Of course, the Americans carried out the attack themselves so as to get an excuse to invade Pakistan.” His colleagues approved his murmurs and he added "4000 American mercenaries are fighting in the FATA area. They are the ones carrying out killings and not the Taliban.” Recently, there has been considerable feeling against the USA due to attacks on Iraq and Afghanistan. This feeling has not diminished the hostility towards India. Surprisingly, in the various seminars and discussions, generally the civil servants take a more moderate line than the elite liberals.

The Pakistani newspaper Nation reported that the bombing of Marriott Hotel on 20 September 2008 was carried out by RAW. It further said that the Pakistan Intelligence Agency has proof that the truck came from the Indian Embassy. Professor Syed Zahir Shah of Islamia College, Islamabad, said with approving nods from his colleagues that "Pakistan Taliban was created by the big powers – the USA, Israel, Russia and India – to destroy Pakistan. It is not the Pakistanis who are carrying out terror attacks. No Pakistani or Muslim killed Benazir Bhutto. She was killed because she was a strong political leader. India, Israel and foreign forces do not want Pakistan to be stable”. When the British journalist pointed out that Taliban had taken the responsibility for the terrorist attack on the Pakistan munitions factory in which more than one hundred citizens had died, he commented "Yes, but they had their reasons. Their women and children had been killed by bombs thrown at the orders of the USA.”

Hafiz Saeed and Musharraf lost no time in blaming India for the terrorist attack on the Army School at Peshawar in which 132 children died and a teacher was burnt alive. Musharraf came out with a weird proposition that 16 December was chosen for the attack because it was the anniversary of Indian victory in 1971. He takes the cake for stating openly in an interview to an American journalist on 24 June 2000 that jihad is not a terrorist and violent phenomenon. It is a "tolerant concept” embodying religious, political and social commitment for safeguarding the dignity and safety of Muslims.

Pakistanis have been fed such propaganda against India and they believe that India wants to break up Pakistan, encourage insurgency in Balochistan and establish friendship with Afghanistan to encircle Pakistan. The Durand Line controversy may be revived. The school text books in the NWFP province promote religious intolerance, hatred and jihad. This theory of fear and suspicion prevails amongst the masses. It would be wrong to believe that only the army and politicians subscribe to such views. To promote trade or business, there has to be assurance of safety of life. My nephew, working for a company in Singapore, was posted to Islamabad. He was allotted a security guard on arrival and warned not to stir out of the hotel without the guard. He was wise enough not to take the family with him. One day, he was shopping in a mall where the Indo-Pakistan cricket match was being shown on a big screen. A Pakistan wicket fell and one of the spectators brought out a gun and fired into the screen. My nephew realized that it was time to quit. We may recall the recent example of the behaviour of Pakistan’s hockey team in India. They got away due to the good sense of Indian spectators. The outcome in Pakistan would have been a tragedy.

Pakistan suffered heavy damage due to floods in 2010. The disaster occurred after heavy rains in Baluchistan. The reaction was that the reason for such floods in the River Indus system was deliberate action by India and demand for control of Kashmir intensified. Friendship and understanding between nations has to be built on common interests and shared threats. Take the example of the UK and France. For more than a century they fought at every occasion and place. They became allies to face the common enemy, Germany. The USA fought a terrible war against Germany and Japan. They are new allies to face Russia or China. Can there be a similar situation for India and Pakistan? Pakistan has only 150 cubic metre water storage capacity per individual – far less than India. Both the countries are likely to face water shortage and could be competing for exploiting natural resources. By cooperation which is unlikely, problems could be made easier. We need to identify common threats and common goals and mere contacts will not help. They enjoy Indian movies and we enjoy Urdu poetry and Ghazals, and more recently Pakistani serials on Zindagi channel. The common liking for entertainment should not be mistaken to be cultural exchange and a step towards political reconciliation.

Brig. SURESH C. SHARMA (Retd.) is advisor to the telecom industry, a freelance writer and a 
member of the Freedom First advisory board. 
Email: sureshsharma236@yahoo.com

 
back

Share

 
 
 

Archive

 
 

Other Articles in this Issue

Between Ourselves...

Between Ourselves

 

The Magna Carta

800th Anniversary of the Signing of the Magna Carta

R. Srinivasan
 

A Tribute to Jamsetji Tata on his 175 Birth Anniversary

Jamshetji Tata Commemorative Coins – A Gesture of the Country’s Gratitude

Dattatraya R. Pendse
 

Honouring Jamsetji Tata on his 175th Birth Anniversary

 

Thank God for the TATA’s – A Tribute

Lakshmi Mittal
 

Narendra Modi and Governance

Thoughts on Recent Political Developments

B. Satyanarayana
 

BJP and Narendra Modi

S. Arunajatesan
 

Obama Visit: An Era of Modi Doctrine

Nitin G. Raut
 

The Delhi Elections

What We Are Worried About

Dharmendra Nagda
 

Muffler Man Muffles Modi's Roar

Dharmendra Nagda
 

The AAP Victory

N R Bala
 

The Spectacular Victory of AAP

Vappala Balachandran
 

Political Paralysis of BJP and Congress

B. N. Mehrish
 

The Anti-Renaissance of Kiran Bedi

Firoze Hirjikaka
 

Delhi Election Result

Phiroze Jhaveri
 

Campaign Financing

 

Point Counter Point : Every issue has at least two side

The Obama Visit

Ashok Karnik
 

The Delhi Jolt

Ashok Karnik
 

Freedom versus Licence

Ashok Karnik
 

The Rural Perspective (1)

Union Budget 2015-16 : Taking Care of Farmers’ Interests

Yalamanchili Sivaji
 

The Rural Perspective (2)

Union Budget 2015-16 Exploitation of Agriculture

Sharad Joshi
 

Foreign Relations in the 21st Century

Global Power Structure in Transition: A New Bipolar World Underway? Part Two

B. Ramesh Babu
 

Will Merkel and Hollande Succeed in De-escalating Conflict in Ukraine?

R. G. Gidadhubli
 

People to People Contact – Cant’ Resolve the Indo-Pakistan Conflict

Suresh C. Sharma
 

Political Transition in Sri Lanka and Its Impact on Asia Balance Of Power

B. N. Mehrish
 

On the Eve of the Union Budget 2015-16

Distortion, Damned Distortion and National Accounts Statistics

Sunil S. Bhandare
 

Educating Adults

‘Nehruvian Ideology and the Indian Celluloid’ Report on a Film Festival in a Mumbai College

Mithilaa Naik-Satam
 

IndianLiberals.in - A Repository for All Indian Liberal Works

 

Sone Ki Chidiya

Supratim Basu
 

Sone Ki Chidiya’s Total Reform Agenda : An Executive Summary

 

Book Review

THE INDIAN FEDERALIST – THE ORIGINAL WILL OF INDIA’S FOUNDING FATHERS

Sanjiv Agarwal
 

Not Just An Accountant : A comment by V.Krishna Moorthy

 

From Our Readers

Freedom First and Always

R C Saxena
 

In defence of Jawaharlal Nehru’s Foreign Policy

B. P. Rastogi
 

Srisailam and Nagarjuna Sagar Reservoirs

T. H. Chowdary
 

One Airport – Two Names

T. H. Chowdary
 

Miscellany

Traffic Offenders are not Felons

 

How to Stop Worrying

Minoo Masani
 

A Definition of “Political Correctness”

 

India’s Greatest Ironies

 

Summit on Countering Violent Extremism

Thomas L. Friedman
 

Greenpeace Vandalism in Peru

 
 
The journal of the Indian Committee for Cultural Freedom
© Copyright Freedom First. All rights reserved.
Freedom First
3rd Floor, Army and Navy Building,
148, Mahatma Gandhi Road,
Mumbai - 400001. INDIA
Tel: +91-22-2284 3416, 6639 6366
Email: freedomfirst1952@gmail.com
Home
Freedom First Archives
Quest Archives
Contact Us
About Us
About ICCF
About Freedom First
About Quest
Publications
Swatantra Party
Introduction
Swatantra Party Documents
Sitemap